The MAT had struck down the appointment of
MeenalJoglekar, KirtiMoharil, VarshaAndhale and Kiran Moghe, after observing
that the three posts from open category were wrongly reserved for women and
only one of the posts should have been reserved. MAT had passed the order on a plea filed by Sanjay Bhokardole, a
candidate for the same post...The MAT observed that Bhokardole’s had
supervisory experience which the selected candidates lacked and held that
candidature for the post ought to be reconsidered.
However, the high court while hearing the plea,
observed that Bhokardole had failed to raise any grounds to prove that his
application for age relaxation was considered by a committee that was not
empowered to do so. The court further recorded that the MAT, too, had failed to
record anything to infer that the selection committee’s findings were
arbitrary.